How accurate is Deadliest Warrior?

which winners do you agree/disagree with and why?

and feature episodes you can think of?How accurate is Deadliest Warrior?
episode 1 i agreed with the Apache was so perfectly trained he couldn't lose



episode 2 no one could argue with that really cause it was only won by 12 so both sides could feel good about it



episode 3 i don't know y there's so much **** about the reenactment its just for entertainment. ninjas weren't trained for head on Spartans were ninjas were all bout assassinations and a Spartan would never be alone.



episode 4 i just didn't get how anything besides the blunderbuss and grenado could kill him the grenado causes blunt force trauma to the whole body and blunderbuss is just a tankHow accurate is Deadliest Warrior?
episode 1 : Have not watched yet, so I cannot comment on this one.



episode 2: So, it's basically a 50/50 even. Samurai by definition is an elite warrior. Not everybody can be a samurai. So, he should have the edge against a viking.



episode 3: Ninja is the shadow warrior which means he always uses his sneak attack and only strike when he can kill his target. Because of that they are like snipers and trained to have close to 99% accuracy. The so called simulation is basically asking a sniper to come out of hiding and fight, let's say, a navy seal, then 'proves' that navy seal is better than sniper. But in reality, we all know who is going to win most of the time.





episode 4: This episode does not make sense at all. The show only calculated the damage of their weapons such as the grenado, but forgot to count that in a real one on one combat situation, how are you going to find the time use the grenado? Beside, the pirate wears no armor, so the knight could just keep using his crossbow from a distance: one shot one kill, game over. Once gets the sword fight, the knight would win simply because knight is used fight sword wielding opponents, but pirates are usually fighting opponents use gun as their primary weapon.





I guess we all see the flaws in show: once you use a computer program to do the thinking for you, you lose all commonsense.How accurate is Deadliest Warrior?
i watched the knight and pirate one. i think the knight got robbed. overall i think the knight would win bc those guns actually used gunpowder and it would take a long time to load the gun. that show is pretty neat idea though.